A CEO’s nightmare is when Mother Nature takes over the management.

There is a fundamental problem with being the Chief Executive of an organisation responsible for hundreds of miles of ageing waterways infrastructure. Mother Nature doesn't recognise the position. writes Alan Yates.

She is unimpressed by six-figure salaries, performance bonuses and impressive business qualifications. Worse still, she has absolutely no respect for the annual budget.

The laws of physics, hydraulics and soil mechanics apply equally to everyone, from the humble lengthsman with muddy boots to the CEO contemplating the latest financial spreadsheet.

You can control expenditure; you cannot control the consequences

On a spreadsheet, preventative maintenance is a wonderfully convenient item. It can be reduced, postponed or, with a sufficiently imaginative accountant, virtually eliminated. The savings are immediate and look splendid in the annual report.

Unfortunately,  water continues to seep through embankments, culverts deteriorate, erosion takes place and gravity remains stubbornly operational twenty-four hours a day.

None of these processes can be suspended

A partially blocked culvert might initially require relatively modest expenditure to investigate and repair. Postpone the work and the obstruction may become a structural failure. Water finds another route, soil begins to disappear and eventually several thousand tonnes of embankment decide to relocate themselves into the surrounding countryside.

The original maintenance saving has now been replaced by a reconstruction bill running into millions.

Mother Nature, meanwhile, continues doing precisely what she was doing before.

Preventative maintenance, when done properly, means nothing happens

Just another uneventful year in which the infrastructure continues to function. A successful maintenance department can therefore appear to be an expensive luxury to executives whose principal measure of success is expenditure against budget.

After all, nothing went wrong last year, so why spend so much money preventing it from possibly going wrong next year? The organisation gradually ceases to manage its infrastructure and begins merely reacting to its deterioration. Eventually, Mother Nature takes complete control of the maintenance schedule. She decides which embankment fails, which culvert collapses and, most inconveniently, when.

The CEO is reduced to the role of an increasingly expensive spectator, desperately trying to contain the consequences of policies previously applauded as prudent financial management.

The final irony

Money that could not be found for preventative maintenance suddenly becomes available in astonishing quantities once the infrastructure has failed.

A spreadsheet can tell a CEO how much money has been spent. It cannot tell them how much damage has been quietly accumulating beneath their feet. And when the inevitable happens, Mother Nature will not be attending the emergency board meeting to explain herself.She will be far too busy preparing the next one.